Uncovering this week's top stories: Nashville Shooting, Ukraine-Russia, Trump's Legal Troubles, and Netanyahu's Reform
Mar 23-30: Using Clarity AI to ask questions and answer them
Good morning! Tired of biased news and information overload? The Clarity Substack is here to cut through the noise and give you a clear view of the world. Our anti-filter approach brings together polarized and fragmented landscapes, so you can see the bigger picture without the confusion.
Here’s what we’ve got in store:
Insights into the past week’s most pressing stories: Nashville, Ukraine, Trump, and Netanyahu
The divide: How the biggest partisan leaning outlets exhibit the Streetlight Effect
Insights into the past week’s most pressing stories
This past week’s top stories, based on the front-page attention, are the following:
Nashville School Shooting
Ukraine-Russia War
Mississippi Tornado Crisis ← Skipping deep dive on this
Trump’s Legal Troubles
Netanyahu’s Judicial Reform
Let’s dive deeper into all of these besides the Tornado Crisis, which doesn’t require nuance to understand its devastating effects.
Nashville School Shooting
What happened in the Nashville school shooting?
On Monday, a mass shooting occurred at the Covenant School, a Christian elementary school in Nashville, killing six people.
The shooter, Audrey E. Hale, was a 28-year-old former student of the school who had legally purchased seven firearms recently, including the three used in the shooting, and was being treated for an emotional disorder.
The police believed that the school and its church had been a target, not any single person, and there were also writings about other locations.
The shooter got into the school by firing through glass doors and climbing through to get inside, then walked through the hallways and pointed an assault-style weapon, surveillance video released by Metro Nashville Police shows.
The police arrived at the scene 11 minutes after the first call about the shooting came in.
The Nashville school shooting is the 19th deadly shooting at a US school or university this year alone.
Sources: 1. New York Times, 2. CNN, 3. CNN
Who were the victims of the Nashville school shooting?
The victims of the Nashville school shooting were three 9-year-olds and three adults. The children were identified as Evelyn Dieckhaus, Hallie Scruggs, and William Kinney, while the adults were Katherine Koonce, Cynthia Peak, and Mike Hill. Koonce was the head of the school, Peak was a substitute teacher, and Hill was a custodian.
Sources: 1. CNN, 2. Washington Post, 3. New York Times
What motivated Audrey Hale to carry out the shooting?
The police have not yet pinpointed a clear motive for the Nashville school shooting carried out by Audrey Hale. However, there is some belief that there was some resentment for having to go to The Covenant School, where she killed three 9-year-old students and three adults. Police Chief John Drake said they are looking into whether Hale’s identity played a role in the slaughter. A search of Hale’s Nashville home turned up a manifesto, as well as detailed maps of the school. Investigators have not determined an official motive and have not revealed the contents of Hale’s manifesto.
Sources: 1. New York Post, 2. New York Post, 3. New York Post
How many firearms did the shooter legally purchase?
The shooter legally purchased seven firearms.
Sources: 1. CNN, 2. Washington Post
What is the emotional disorder the shooter was being treated for?
The shooter who killed three children and three adults at a Christian grade school in Nashville on Monday was under a doctor's care for an "emotional disorder". However, the specific type of emotional disorder has not been disclosed.
Sources: 1. Reuters
Ukraine-Russia War
A lot happened this past week - here’s the gist:
Ukraine admits Russian gains and a U.S. reporter is arrested.
Ukrainians are directing soldiers from a hidden hub and are optimistic about Bakhmut.
Putin is using scare tactics to distract from his problems.
Russian eyes are always watching on the front line.
A Muslim minority in Crimea is facing a crackdown by Russia.
European businesses survived the Ukraine War and energy shock.
Ukraine is held back by slow deliveries despite being pumped up by Western weapons.
Why was a US reporter arrested in Russia?
A US reporter named Evan Gershkovich was arrested in Russia by the FSB (Russia's security agency) in the Urals industrial city of Yekaterinburg. He was accused of spying in the interests of the American government and illegally gathering information about one of the enterprises of Russia's military-industrial complex. The FSB provided no evidence to support their claims. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said he understood Gershkovich had been "caught red-handed".
Sources: 1. Reuters 2. Washington Post
What is the current situation in Bakhmut?
The situation in Bakhmut is tense, with Ukrainian troops digging in and Russian forces becoming depleted. Ukrainian General Oleksandr Syrskyi has said that a counter-offensive could soon be launched, while the International Committee of the Red Cross reports that thousands of Ukrainian civilians, many elderly and with disabilities, are suffering "very dire conditions" in and around Bakhmut. The fighting in and around Bakhmut has been the most violent of recent months and does not appear to be letting up, with Russian and Ukrainian officials expressing this week an unwillingness to yield.
Sources: 1. CNN, 2. Reuters, 3. New York Times
What is the situation of the Muslim minority in Crimea?
The Muslim minority in Russian-occupied Crimea, specifically the Crimean Tatars, are facing a crackdown by Moscow due to their loyalty to Kyiv. The Tatars consider Crimea their historic homeland and made up 12% of the area's population before Russia's illegal annexation. Rights groups are raising the alarm about Moscow's persecution campaign against the Tatar community, with nearly 200,000 ethnic Crimean Tatars deported from Crimea by Soviet authorities in the 1940s. Currently, there are 181 political prisoners, 116 of whom are ethnic Tatars, and Tatars make up almost 65% of those prisoners. Ukraine's President's permanent representative in Crimea fears for the Tatar community, which has a long history of oppression, and is calling for the return of Crimea to Ukraine.
Sources: 1. NBC News
Trump’s Legal Troubles
Note: It’s debatable how important this topic is and it exposes a flaw in Clarity’s algorithm. MSNBC placed so much front-page attention on this that it outweighed the rest of the left. One possible improvement to the algorithm is to filter outliers in the attention distribution before ranking.
What legal battles and investigations currently surround former President Trump?
Former President Trump is facing several investigations.
The Justice Department is still seeking testimony from Trump defense attorney Evan Corcoran, after he cited attorney-client privilege, as well as from another Trump lawyer, Jennifer Little.
The special counsel is overseeing a parallel investigation into Mr. Trump’s efforts to reverse his defeat at the polls in 2020 and his role in the events that led to the storming of the Capitol by his supporters on Jan. 6, 2021.
Prosecutors are working to assemble evidence that Mr. Trump could have committed a crime in defying the government’s efforts to reclaim the classified materials he took with him after leaving the White House.
There is a separate yearslong investigation into his alleged role in a scheme to pay hush money to an adult film star.
How is Donald Trump responding to these charges?
Donald Trump is denouncing efforts by the Manhattan district attorney’s office to indict him, calling the possible criminal charges politically motivated to tarnish his reputation ahead of a crucial election cycle.
Trump is lamenting the ongoing investigation by Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg as being “rigged” by Democrats, arguing the inquiry was being used to make him ineligible for the 2024 presidential election.
At his first official campaign rally in Waco, Texas, Trump called for the ouster of the top officials spearheading investigations against him, arguing that top officials were unfairly targeting him and ignoring more pressing concerns.
Trump is also calling for the removal of District Attorney Bragg, Radical Lunatic Bombthrower Jack Smith, Letitia James, the worst Attorney General in the United States, and Atlanta D.A. Fani Willis, who he says is trying to make perfect phone calls into a plot to destroy America.
Trump's acolytes are interested in taking a look at how Congress funds law enforcement and have written a letter to the Manhattan district attorney calling for congressional scrutiny about how public safety funds appropriated by Congress are implemented by local law-enforcement agencies.
Sources: 1. Washington Examiner, 2. MSNBC, 3. Washington Examiner, 4. New York Times
What is the potential outcome of Trump's legal troubles?
Manhattan District Attorney, Alvin Bragg, is examining the evidence and relevant law to decide whether to prosecute Trump or not.
Trump's status as a former president and the political fallout that will likely accompany his indictment will not be taken into account in the decision-making process.
Trump's claims of arrest may have improved his legal woes by creating a media firestorm and putting pressure on the DA's office not to go that last step.
Reports emerged stating the grand jury overseeing Bragg's investigation would not hear the Trump case, resulting in a delay of a potential indictment of the former president until at least next week.
Trump is facing three other legal probes, which are weightier than the New York case, involving the attack on Jan. 6, his effort to overturn election results in Georgia, and his possession of classified documents at Mar-a-Lago.
Trying to anticipate his strength or weakness in the fall of 2024 is risky, but viewed in the context of the gathering 2024 Republican nomination contest, the past few days have shown that indictments or threats of them can boost him, at least temporarily.
Sources: 1. Washington Times, 2. Washington Examiner, 3. Washington Post
Netanyahu’s Judicial Reform
Gist: Israel's Prime Minister Netanyahu faces pressure and protests over his proposed judicial overhaul plan, leading to a general strike and the firing of the defense minister, but has now agreed to pause the reform.
What is Netanyahu's proposed judicial overhaul plan?
Netanyahu's proposed judicial overhaul plan would allow the government to choose judges, potentially including those presiding over his own corruption trial. The plan has faced widespread opposition and protests, with concerns that it could lead to a slide towards dictatorship and a threat to democracy. Netanyahu has vowed to push through the overhaul despite objections from the attorney general, and has fired the defense minister who called for a halt to the plan. However, he has delayed the plan after unprecedented strikes and protests. The Supreme Court may potentially have to decide on laws curbing its own power, leading to a constitutional standoff.
Sources: 1. Washington Post, 2. Washington Post, 3. CNN, 4. Washington Post
Why did Netanyahu fire the defense minister?
Netanyahu fired Defense Minister Yoav Gallant because he called for a halt to the controversial plan to overhaul Israel's judiciary, which has sparked widespread protests across the country. The decision to fire Gallant was an attempt to quell dissent against the judicial overhaul plan, which would give Israel's parliament the ability to overrule Supreme Court rulings. Netanyahu argued that the reforms were necessary to streamline the legislative process and stave off judicial overreach. However, critics of Netanyahu, including opposition leader Yair Lapid, have assailed the move, calling it "a new low for an anti-Zionist government that is harming national security and ignoring the warnings of all security figures." The proposal has also drawn consternation from multiple allies of Israel, such as the United States.
Sources: 1. Wall Street Journal, 2. Washington Examiner, 3. Washington Post, 4. Washington Post
The divide
It's difficult to understand how the media you consume is shaping your perspective. We’re all swimming in our own, personalized filter bubbles, and often only see information that confirms our existing beliefs and opinions.
This phenomenon is exaggerated by the streetlight effect. Different news outlets shine a light on different aspects of reality, and it's easy to get caught up in one perspective without seeing the full picture. This can lead to a distorted understanding of events and issues.
MSNBC and Fox News are considered by many the primary left and right-wing cable media outlets. What is each outlet focused on, measured by front-page attention?
Was there anything you missed? Follow the heated discussion on Reddit!
That’s it for this week. To see a full rundown of the biggest stories of the week or the past 24 hours, check out useclarity.com. And if you’re curious, here’s how it works.